Is there anything wrong with dancing?

No, dancing is not bad in itself. In fact, many different people from various cultures have performed their dances for the Pope himself... including break-dancers. It is very obvious that the Catholic Church does not see dance as a sinful action, but as a beautiful expression of culture and a decent form of entertainment.

However, it is clear that not all dance fits under those two categories of beauty and decency. I'm going to talk about "dirty dancing," "grinding," or the type of dance that goes on in a club, or homecoming dance in high school and even middle school. Why do we dance in such a strange way? I would venture to say that there are two main reasons our generation dances the way it dances:
1. because we are extremely obedient, and 2. because it feels good. The second reason simply supports the first, because we are also very obedient in things that do not feel good at all, such as wearing high heels while our feet almost bleed and plucking eyebrows until they look unnaturally tiny. So the main motivation is obedience

Whom do we obey, you may want to know? Certainly not our parents. Not our grandparents. Not our religion and probably not our consciences. I think there are a couple different answers. But let's go with Fred. We obey Fred… indirectly, maybe, but we obey him. Fred is a very rich man. He lives in California. He sits in a big office. How did he get rich? He paid beautiful women to wear almost nothing and "dance" with beautiful men on TV. Why would he pay them to do such a thing? Because he wants to improve society, or do something good in the world? No, he paid them to do that because sex sells. Sex sells and we bought it; we bought into it. And that was his plan, because he wants us to buy not just the dance, but the clothes on their bodies, the rings on their fingers, and the make-up on their faces. Some of us buy the accessories, and almost all of us imitate their movements exactly; or at least try to... We obey Fred blindly.

So after obedience, I would argue that our generation "grinds" because it feels good. The Church has nothing against things that feel good. Eating, for example, feels good. But it also nourishes us. Sleeping, as well, has an element of pleasure to it, but it also gives us the energy we need to keep going. You could say that we go on vacation just because we like it, but it also gives us time to spend with our family and rest. So. We dance like that because it feels good, but it also… wait… no… it has nothing else to offer us but pleasure, and a kind of a bad taste in our mouths when we go home and realize that we have just been used (that is if we are brave enough to really think about what happened). That's the problem with pleasure that has no end, no fulfillment, no purpose: if you seek it, in the end it leads you to take advantage of and to use other people's bodies, and your own.

For those reasons, I think it is safe to say that "dirty dancing" is in fact bad, and is indeed sinful. So this is my proposal to my generation: Don't obey Fred. Don't let him make any more money off of you. Don't let your life be led by empty pleasures. Recognize your dignity, and that of those around you. And finally receive the sacraments and pray in order to receive the strength to do so.

If you want to seek more advice write us at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. or read "Still Struggling?".

 


Hna.KristinM AltoyClaro

My name is Sr. Kristin María of Jesus and of the Immaculate Virgin. I was perfectly content in my idyllic little bubble called Naples, Florida when I met the Servant Sisters of the Home of the Mother, who opened my heart to truths so intense and so beautiful that what I thought was reality suddenly popped and I saw beyond. They introduced me to the person of Jesus Christ, who attracted me to Himself so strongly that I could no longer imagine belonging to anyone but Him. After tossing and turning, weighing and discerning, falling and rising, He gave me the strength to leave behind my dreams of academic prestige to follow Him on the narrow path of humility and poverty. Since then, I have been living in Spain and Italy, completing my formation, teaching catechism, studying theology, and writing this blog.